Skip to main contents
Artwork for X-Men: Days of Future Past

X-Men: Days of Future Past

Score
9.50

I'd never thought I'd see this storyline brought to life, but Singer nails it in every way, taking a potentially confusing and convoluted story and bringing an entertaining multi-era character arc to a satisfying conclusion. Amazing.

Artwork for Captain Marvel

Captain Marvel

Score
9.00

Brie Larson shines, finally bringing a female lead story to the forefront of the MCU - with a subtle, wry wit, in a story with more than a few surprises.

Artwork for Deadpool

Deadpool

Score
9.00

Best comic book costume onscreen since Superman. Entertaining, captures the character perfectly, the passion shows in the production.

Artwork for Guardians of the Galaxy

Guardians of the Galaxy

Score
9.00

This movie had no right to be this good, but Gunn deftly executed a brilliant vision, coupling beautiful art direction, a great sense of humor, and heartfelt emotional resonance with fantastic pacing and a strong cast.

Artwork for Superman

Superman

Score
9.00

A pioneer film, Donner chose to elevate the story and character of Superman to the highest level, with a great understanding of how to build up a hero and the choices it takes.

Artwork for X-Men 2

X-Men 2

Score
9.00

Another rare case of the sequel being better than the first film, Singer executes almost flawlessly, bringing to bear great storywriting and characterization of mutants in our world.

Artwork for Dredd

Dredd

Score
8.80

If you ever read a Judge Dredd comic, this movie is a must see. In some ways, it might be the truest adaptation of a hero to film ever.

Artwork for Spider-Man 2

Spider-Man 2

Score
8.80

A fantastic extension of the first movie, this one builds off the last and emotionally creates a great springboard to feel the true weight of being a hero and paying the price.

Artwork for Iron Man

Iron Man

Score
8.70

RDJ brings the character to life in a true commitment to the character that will indelibly change the Marvel Movie Universe, laying the groundwork for great things to come. Well directed, this movie shows the heart of a hero in every sense and carries itself with feeling and a great sense of humor.

Artwork for Logan

Logan

Score
8.50

Logan is a fantastic omega opus for the Hugh Jackman's Wolverine, with true heart in a masterfully shaped dystopia.

Artwork for Ant-Man

Ant-Man

Score
8.20

Marvel Universe game-changer, bringing a character only known to comic fans and giving us a story with mainstream appeal that was much aligned.

Artwork for The Dark Knight Rises

The Dark Knight Rises

Score
8.20

A cap to an amazing trilogy, Nolan brings to bear many of the same standards of the past two movies - it fails to deliver on a few counts for me - mostly involving a few suspect plot points and some overly convenient plot devices. They did the unthinkable - they let Batman be happy.

Artwork for Blade

Blade

Score
8.00

A great movie, and an amazing start to the Marvel empire. They took a solid C character and brought it to life with a beautiful visual style and some stellar fight choreography.

Artwork for Spider-Man

Spider-Man

Score
8.00

A great return to form at the hands of Raimi, some fantastic work that gives the right nods to the material, lifting it up while allowing Tobey to truly inhabit the role.

Artwork for Watchmen

Watchmen

Score
8.00

Zack is very good at bringing to life, panel for panel, the original work with a fanboy like homage. This movie is no exception and makes some great choices to make the series work in movie format - sometimes it's bit silly (sex scene - yikes) but for the most part it honors well the great work by Moore.

Artwork for The Wolverine

The Wolverine

Score
8.00

A great depiction of a crucial storyline in the character's history, this movie has a lot working for it, though Viper seems unnecessary and more time should have been spent in the central family conflict.

Artwork for Road to Perdition

Road to Perdition

Score
7.80

Mendes delivers a great character study and a touching story in a gangster drama gone wrong. Hanks delivers a serious, committed role with some beautiful cinematography and great tension.

Artwork for X-Men: First Class

X-Men: First Class

Score
7.50

I didn't expect to enjoy this, but it is a great exploration of the origins of the team and succeeds in providing a fantastic vehicle for Fassbender to shine as a focal point. Some of the other characters seem superfluous (white queen, Angel) but still well crafted.

Artwork for Constantine

Constantine

Score
7.30

The movie does an admirable job of capturing the spirit and suspense of Hellblazer's worlds and Reeves inhabits the role well, even if it's not quite the version we would have wanted (see the TV series for that version).

Artwork for From Hell

From Hell

Score
7.30

A well crafted, well art directed film, this film is a great story, but very far removed from the original material.

Artwork for Conan the Barbarian

Conan the Barbarian

Score
6.80

Milius delivers a complete vision for the character and Arnie does deliver in a role meant for him. The film is lifted by a great performance by James Earl Jones and well-realized art direction.

Artwork for Mystery Men

Mystery Men

Score
6.80

This movie actually gets funnier to me over multiple watchings, it has some great moments and great characters, if a little flat in it's writing on occassion.

Artwork for Superman Returns

Superman Returns

Score
6.80

Singer is very reverential to Donner's vision, serving up a modern sequel to Superman 1 and 2. It suffers for the very same reason and lacks enough conflict or emotion to make it truly meaningful, as much as we would like it to.

Artwork for Hulk

Hulk

Score
6.70

Ang Lee takes a risk on trying to bring the medium to life - comic panels and all - and equating the source of the hulk's rage to an abusive source. It suffers from a convoluted ending in which the movie tries to tie up too much at once.

Artwork for Iron Man 3

Iron Man 3

Score
6.70

A fun movie for RDJ to play in, while it was refreshing to see him fight without the suit, it is relatively empty in it's emotional weight.

Artwork for The Phantom

The Phantom

Score
6.50

A fun, pulpy romp that honors the work before it, while attempting to modernize it for this age. It succeeds more than it fails.

Artwork for The Amazing Spider-Man 2

The Amazing Spider-Man 2

Score
6.50

A good extension of the first movie, deepening the history of Pete's father and some great visual moments with introduction to the Sinister Six, but the Electro story is a tad embarrassing and shoddily written.

Artwork for Batman Forever

Batman Forever

Score
6.30

They took some time on developing Bruce Wayne - Kilmer brings a level of believability to the conflict within and an emotional depth that was lacking in the first two.

Artwork for 300

300

Score
6.00

Snyder captures the material directly, bringing together frame for frame a film version of the graphic novel, a classic Grecian tale brought to brutal, bloody life. That being said, not much new is brought to this.

Artwork for Judge Dredd

Judge Dredd

Score
5.30

Stallone does an admirable attempt at capturing the spirit of the character, but the comedic Schneider is a waste of time in a film that meanders to it's predictable end.

Artwork for Daredevil

Daredevil

Score
5.00

This movie is Phantom Menace bad. Wildly disappointing. Daredevil is a champion of the true comic fan and this movie is an injustice.

Artwork for R.I.P.D.

R.I.P.D.

Score
5.00

They spent a lot of money on effects, and Jeff Bridges is fun to watch, but Reynolds is the same character again, and the movie is ultimately forgettable.

Artwork for Elektra

Elektra

Score
4.50

I love Jennifer Garner, and the character, but this movie strays far from the source material to deliver an uninspired, bland romp.

Artwork for Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer

Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer

Score
4.30

Plagued by many problems - commitment to the roles, this movie squanders the chance to use some of the greatest storylines in FF history - the surfer and the world-eater. The surfer is better handled but the character interplay is unbelievable and goofy.

Artwork for Fantastic Four

Fantastic Four

Score
3.30

On paper, this film has all the elements of the right elements - a solid character driven director, a gritty sci-fi tone, and some stellar hot talent. In practice, the studio conflicts and director meltdowns led to a fractured experience that presents itself as such, with points of brilliance side by side with flat, inane, dreck. What a waste.

Artwork for Supergirl

Supergirl

Score
3.30

An interesting extension to the Donner work, Supergirl is earnestly played by Slater and surrounded by a lot of over the top performances by renowned actors.

Artwork for Man of Steel

Man of Steel

Score
3.00

Watching Snyder work is like watching a 12 year old boy direct Citizen Kane. Stylistically, he still has some great visual highlights - Krypton, an powerful foe, a new way to find purpose - but he fouls a lot of it up, breaking a cardinal rule with no real sense of consequence - an unfortunate kickoff to a new DCU.

Artwork for Red Sonja

Red Sonja

Score
2.50

Forgettable, poorly acted and directed, this a sad homage to the character but at least she didn't run around in a chain mail bikini. Perhaps it should have been a comedy.