Skip to main contents
Artwork for The Avengers

The Avengers

Score
9.99

It's the impossible dream. Big budget. Joss Whedon. Iron Man. Hulk. Thor. Cap. Black Widow. Hawkeye. Nick Fury. IN THE SAME MOVIE.

Artwork for Deadpool

Deadpool

Score
9.00

Best comic book costume onscreen since Superman. Entertaining, captures the character perfectly, the passion shows in the production.

Artwork for X-Men 2

X-Men 2

Score
9.00

Another rare case of the sequel being better than the first film, Singer executes almost flawlessly, bringing to bear great storywriting and characterization of mutants in our world.

Artwork for Doctor Strange

Doctor Strange

Score
8.90

They achieved the impossible dream - bring a dearly loved character to the screen straight from Ditko's art with the right depth and perfect casting.

Artwork for Dredd

Dredd

Score
8.80

If you ever read a Judge Dredd comic, this movie is a must see. In some ways, it might be the truest adaptation of a hero to film ever.

Artwork for Captain America: The First Avenger

Captain America: The First Avenger

Score
8.70

This movie exceeded my expectations - Joe makes the absolute right choices: making this a period piece, making skinny Steve Rogers believable and allowing great insight into what makes this hero. The last half of the movie suffers some timing issues but it's a great launchpad.

Artwork for Logan

Logan

Score
8.50

Logan is a fantastic omega opus for the Hugh Jackman's Wolverine, with true heart in a masterfully shaped dystopia.

Artwork for Ant-Man

Ant-Man

Score
8.20

This movie excels despite it's rocky inception. Rudd is solid in the role and Michael Peña brings a great comedic presence - it surprises and delights.

Artwork for Blade

Blade

Score
8.00

A great movie, and an amazing start to the Marvel empire. They took a solid C character and brought it to life with a beautiful visual style and some stellar fight choreography.

Artwork for Hellboy

Hellboy

Score
7.80

A great visualization to the printed work, Mignola's character is brought forth in a visceral, solid magnitude, with incredible set pieces and a defining performace by Perlman.

Artwork for Sin City

Sin City

Score
7.80

Visually stunning, and comic accurate, it captures the sex and violence of Miller's work to the letter. Whether you would want to read the letter, kind of depends on your tolerance for it.

Artwork for Iron Man 2

Iron Man 2

Score
7.70

A lot of things go well for the movie - War Machine, Black Widow intro, Mickey Rourke, great action sequences by Tartakovsky. Some of the drama seems a bit artificial and clunky at times, but is still an enjoyable watch.

Artwork for Aquaman

Aquaman

Score
7.50

I had some pretty low expectations but was pleasantly surprised by the scope and scale of Aquaman, they aimed for epic and mostly got there.

Artwork for The Amazing Spider-Man

The Amazing Spider-Man

Score
7.50

Definitely more Ultimate Spiderman than the first trilogy, the movie captures a lot of the spirit of the same series and carries through with a lot of serviceable action but is ultimately 'meh'

Artwork for X-Men: First Class

X-Men: First Class

Score
7.50

I didn't expect to enjoy this, but it is a great exploration of the origins of the team and succeeds in providing a fantastic vehicle for Fassbender to shine as a focal point. Some of the other characters seem superfluous (white queen, Angel) but still well crafted.

Artwork for Constantine

Constantine

Score
7.30

The movie does an admirable job of capturing the spirit and suspense of Hellblazer's worlds and Reeves inhabits the role well, even if it's not quite the version we would have wanted (see the TV series for that version).

Artwork for Red

Red

Score
7.00

Solid performances from a great cast, Red details some great character interaction coupled with a fun plotline, mingled well with some well choreographed fight sequences.

Artwork for Conan the Barbarian

Conan the Barbarian

Score
6.80

Milius delivers a complete vision for the character and Arnie does deliver in a role meant for him. The film is lifted by a great performance by James Earl Jones and well-realized art direction.

Artwork for Mystery Men

Mystery Men

Score
6.80

This movie actually gets funnier to me over multiple watchings, it has some great moments and great characters, if a little flat in it's writing on occassion.

Artwork for Superman Returns

Superman Returns

Score
6.80

Singer is very reverential to Donner's vision, serving up a modern sequel to Superman 1 and 2. It suffers for the very same reason and lacks enough conflict or emotion to make it truly meaningful, as much as we would like it to.

Artwork for Iron Man 3

Iron Man 3

Score
6.70

A fun movie for RDJ to play in, while it was refreshing to see him fight without the suit, it is relatively empty in it's emotional weight.

Artwork for The Amazing Spider-Man 2

The Amazing Spider-Man 2

Score
6.50

A good extension of the first movie, deepening the history of Pete's father and some great visual moments with introduction to the Sinister Six, but the Electro story is a tad embarrassing and shoddily written.

Artwork for Blade II

Blade II

Score
6.40

Del Toro brings a nightmare creature to life - a monster that eats monsters - in a fun piece that enhances the Blade mythos, and brings more of what was built in Blade 1 to fruition.

Artwork for 300

300

Score
6.00

Snyder captures the material directly, bringing together frame for frame a film version of the graphic novel, a classic Grecian tale brought to brutal, bloody life. That being said, not much new is brought to this.

Artwork for Daredevil

Daredevil

Score
5.00

This movie is Phantom Menace bad. Wildly disappointing. Daredevil is a champion of the true comic fan and this movie is an injustice.

Artwork for R.I.P.D.

R.I.P.D.

Score
5.00

They spent a lot of money on effects, and Jeff Bridges is fun to watch, but Reynolds is the same character again, and the movie is ultimately forgettable.

Artwork for Batman

Batman

Score
4.70

This is considered by many to be a giant step in the evolution of a new, more serious Batman. In direct opposition of the '66 spoofy Batman, Burton sought to create an art deco city that housed a much more intense Batman than we've seen up to this point. The building blocks are there for Nolan to complete the transition to his masterwork. Nicholson owns the role, if campy and Keaton embraces the role, if a little silly at times.

Artwork for Elektra

Elektra

Score
4.50

I love Jennifer Garner, and the character, but this movie strays far from the source material to deliver an uninspired, bland romp.

Artwork for Wanted

Wanted

Score
4.50

Points for taking a ridiculous story and trying to give a new life in the form of a bombastic Hollywood Gun-Fu movie.

Artwork for The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Score
3.30

A valiant attempt at trying to bring the piece to life, it fails on quite a few fronts, including the idiotic need to bring in an American character - tom sawyer - as an insult to American viewing audiences. It does capture Nemo, Jekyll and other in a good depiction but ultimately feels forced.

Artwork for Dick Tracy

Dick Tracy

Score
2.30

I appreciate the fact they tried to bring the characters to life, with some huge prosthetics and makeup but it felt flat and unexciting.

Artwork for The Spirit

The Spirit

Score
0.30

Impossible to comprehend how Frank Miller could get Eisner so wrong. It's like the most respected musician in the world recording lost Beatles songs and making them unlistenable.